Comparison Between Products in Your Market

(Scroll to the left if on mobile to see full table)

Shingle Name
Score
Nails Required (High Wind)
Warranty
Wind Warranty (Regular App)
Wind Warranty (Special App)
Impact Resistance
BP Mystique ★★★★
6 Nails
Limited Lifetime
110 mph
135 mph
Yes, Class 3
BP Manior ★★★★
6 Nails
Limited Lifetime
110 mph
135 mph
Yes, Class 3
IKO Cambridge ★★★
6 Nails
Limited Lifetime
130 mph
130 mph
No
IKO Dynasty ★★★★
6 Nails
Limited Lifetime
130 mph
130 mph
Yes, Class 3
IKO Nordic ★★★★★
6 Nails
Limited Lifetime
130 mph
130 mph
Yes, Class 4
GAF Timberline HDZ ★★★
6 Nails
Limited Lifetime
130 mph
130 mph
No
GAF Timberline NS ★★★
6 Nails
Limited Lifetime
130 mph
130 mph
No
Tamko Heritage ★★★
6 Nails
Limited Lifetime
110 mph
130 mph
No
Tamko Titan XT ★★★★
4 Nails*
Limited Lifetime
110 mph
160 mph
No
Tamko Stortmfighter IR ★★★★★
4 Nails*
Limited Lifetime
110 mph
160 mph
Yes, Class 4
* with TAMKO Starter 
*All of the information listed was obtained through the manufacturer’s websites. The grades were assigned based off of the weighted columns listed in the table.*